Tanner [Sean Cody] vs. Briley Pierce

Tanner is a young versatile stud from Sean Cody who always seems to have a smile. He comes in at 5'10 and 176 lbs. Pierce comes in at 6'2" and 209 lb and is Dolph Ziggler's brother.

Pierce waits in the ring as his novice opponent nervously walks down the ramp to the ring. Tanner smiles to the crowd, but his nerves are visible to all. He climbs into the ring and Pierce wastes no time and jumps on him, knocking him in the head with repeated blows, sending the young porn stud onto his back. Briley picks him up by the head and Irish whips him into the corner turnbuckles, the impact so hard that Tanner falls flat on his back again. Pierce slides down and gets Tanner in a headlock, smiling at how panicked the buff porn star is already. Tanner squirms around, but Pierce punches him in the head to stabilize him. He then puts Tanner's head on top of the bottom rope and chokes him until the ref breaks it up. Tanner crawls away gasping for air, but Pierce is on him again, picking him up and punching him in the face. Tanner staggers back into the corner and Pierce hits a shoulder thrust on him. Tanner is so exhausted he wants to cry, but he knows he'll have to fight back. He kicks at Pierce, but Pierce catches his foot and then clotheslines him. He picks Tanner back up just to dropkick him. Tanner falls back to the ring and Pierce rolls him on his back for the pin, but the porn star punches out after one. Pierce picks Tanner back up and whips him across the ring, the young stud ducks the clothesline attempt and springs back with a flying forearm, sending Pierce on his back. Tanner lands on top of him and delivers a series of blows that has Pierce squirming. Tanner then picks the wrestler up and uppercuts him. Pierce stumbles back into the ropes. Tanner grabs him by the head and does a one-handed bulldog, slamming Pierce to the ring. He crawls on top of the pro for the pin, but Pierce easily punches out after one. Tanner picks Pierce back up and slings his arm over his shoulder. He goes for a suplex, but Pierce blocks it, and reverses it, sending Tanner slamming down. Tanner is able to get to his feet relatively fast, but Pierce is behind him already, picking him up and nailing a wheelbarrow facebuster. He holds Tanner down for a pin, but Tanner thrusts out after a two count. Pierce is tired too, and picks Tanner up ready to suplex him again, but pauses to catch his breath. Tanner takes this opportunity to swing out of it and clothesline Pierce. Tanner then dashes to the top turnbuckle for an aerial attack. Pierce stands up, dazed and Tanner leaps at him with a missile dropkick, connecting. He lays on top of the sweaty wrestler for the pin, but gets a two-count. Tanner gets to his feet knowing he has to stay on Pierce, but he's tired. He picks the wrestler up in a fireman's carry, but Pierce slides out of it and gets behind Tanner lifting him up and hitting a half nelson reverse facebuster. Tanner falls face first into the mat hard, but before he can get up Pierce grabs his foot and holds him in an ankle lock. At first Tanner thinks he'll be able to kick out of it, but Pierce has it tight. He reaches for the rope, but Tanner pulls him back close. Tanner can't take the pain anymore and screams as he taps out furiously. Pierce releases the hold throwing Tanner's leg back down, smirking at his fallen victim. He walks over to him and flings his sweat down on his loser opponent.

Tanner enters the frat house, it was quiet. Most of the brothers, no all of the brothers, were at a Sorority toga party, as was he as a matter of minutes ago. But his big brother called him here, and he was still a pledge so he had to leave. Tanner calls for Pierce, but doesn't hear a reply. Tanner holds the bottom of his toga up as he heads upstairs to check Pierce's room. He sees from the end of the hall his door is closed. As he makes his way he can't help but feel relieved to leave that sorority party, being pressured to hook up with girls, that was not his thing. He thought his brothers realized that he was gay when they offered him to pledge, but he guesses not so much now. 
He taps on Pierce's door. "Come in."
Tanner opens the door and sees Pierce, sitting on his couch, his skin oiled up and wearing nothing but short shorts with a camouflage pattern. On the TV is porn. Gay porn. Is this a joke? A trap? "I called you over to see if you wanted to help a brother out," Pierce explains rubbing his crotch.
Tanner still doesn't know if it's a trap and so he dumbly replies, "With what?"
Pierce reads Tanner's nerves and stands right up to him. Tanner can feel his breath and then Pierce feels down Tanner's shoulders and arms and leans in for a kiss. It's a soft peck, but Pierce kisses him again, opening his mouth and letting Tanner's tongue slide in. The two make out standing in the middle of the room with the door wide open.
It doesn't take long for Pierce to undo Tanner's tog revealing his impressive body, with a patch of fur around his chest. Pierce kisses it and looks at Tanner with a smile. Tanner directs Pierce to sit on the couch and then straddles his lap. They kiss almost continuously feeling each others bodies -- and muscles -- with no signs of slowing down.
Tanner then strokes down at Pierce's lap, feeling his boner. Pierce's dick pokes out of his short shorts, getting more and more turned on by Tanner's dominance. Tanner slides off the couch on to the floor sitting up on his knees he takes in Pierce's dick. He sucks the cock hard, letting his tongue and lips glide up and down the shaft so his nose pokes Pierce's stomach. Pierce combs his hands threw Tanner's hair as he sighs from the job he's receiving. Tanner takes the dick out of his mouth, looking up at Pierce as he taps the head on the end of his tongue before inhaling it again. He strokes the cock as he goes, twisting around the base while his mouth worked the head. Pierce twitches with excitement as Tanner knows all the right motions to make -- and Tanner feeds off that excitement to keep it going.
He slurps the dick out of his mouth and then slides Pierce's short shorts off him completely. He nods with approval at the naked wrestler's body and then climbs on to Pierce's lap. He gives the wrestler a kiss and then grabs the cock to aim up his hole. Pierce can't believe it -- no lube necessary -- as his cock slides up in the young pornstar's hole. "Ahhh," Tanner sighs with a slight giggle.
He puts his hands on Pierce's oily chest, pressing down on and then gyrates his bubble butt on his lap. Pierce sighs, never imagining that he'd be recreating the positions he'd been watching on his gay porn video. He cups Tanner's butt as the young buck bounces up and down on the dick. Their skin smacks together quietly as Tanner holds on to Pierce's shoulders for support.
"Yeah, that's it fuck me," Tanner coos.
Pierce grunts as he begins to thrust up faster, feeling Tanner's insides clench up trying to hold on to his dick as long as possible.
"Mmm, awww..." Tanner sighs.
Pierce keeps him bouncing on his lap as he slouches down on the couch practically horizontal. Tanner's cock waves in front of his face and finally he can't resist and opens his mouth, sucking the dick as he thrusts his up in Tanner.
"Aww, fuck," Tanner moans, squeezing Pierce's shoulders, "Ahhh...."
Tanner rotates half way, putting his foot on the couch as a balance and rides up and down the dick. "Ah, yeah, fuck it," Tanner sighs, "Mmm..."
Pierce just groans as his hands feel up Tanner's abs and squeeze his chest. Pierce sits back up and slides Tanner back down on to the floor. Tanner rests on his shoulders staring up at the ceiling as Pierce holds his legs and drills his dick down in him. "Ohhh fuck," Tanner sighs as the dick digs deeper into. "Yeah, that's it, fuck me," Tanner says as Pierce pulls out.
He nods and drills his cock back down gyrating when it's halfway in. "Ahhhh," Tanner sighs louder.
Pierce picks his dick back out and then thrusts it back in and repeats a steady motion that keeps Tanner moaning. Tanner's dick swings in front of his face as he moans more. He loves his view of Pierce hovering over him, or so it seems, fucking him hard. "Mmm, ahhh..." Tanner moans. "You like that cock?"
Pierce finally says something. "Mmm hmm."
Tanner sighs stroking his hard dick.
"How would you like some ass?"
Tanner licks his lips and nods. Pierce pulls his dick out of the porn star and positions himself on the couch so his ass hangs over the edge. Tanner crawls over to it, flicking his tongue at the hole before slurping up and down the crack. Pierce sighs, "Oh yeah..." surprised to find Tanner giving him a rim job.
Tanner spits in the hole and wipes it in with his tongue as Pierce squeezes his grip to the couch. Tanner slides a finger in him, finding it surprisingly looser than he'd thought. He was actually a little disappointed not being Pierce's first. Nonetheless he sits on his knees and guides his cock in the wrestler's round ass. "Ahhh..." Pierce moans as the dick goes halfway in. "Yeah, right there. Fuck me."
Tanner obeys pounding the wrestler in a pace that matched his, listening to Pierce moan with pleasure. Tanner can't believe that he's fucking his frat brother -- sober -- and in the frat house. So many fantasies coming to life at once. He focuses on his fucking, rubbing his hands gently up and down Pierce's lower back as the two studs hear their skin smacking together. Tanner forces his dick in further and grinds it in the wrestler. Pierce shrieks with delight, arching his back up allowing Tanner to pull him in for a kiss. Tanner keeps pounding at him, loving the way his ass feels. Pierce pushes back on the thrusts, bouncing on the dick a bit until he screams. Did Tanner hurt him?
"Ahhhhh! I'm about to burst," Pierce moans.
Tanner fucks faster, the increased speed multiplies the climax Pierce feels and his moans become gasps for air as he strokes his load out of his dick on to the couch.
"Ahhhhhh!" Pierce yells in between breaths. "Fuck, yeah."
Tanner freezes his fucking and pulls Pierce back to him for another kiss. "I'm gonna cum too."
Before Tanner can slide his dick out Pierce replies, "Cum in me."
He then bounces his ass back on Tanner's dick and within moments Tanner sighs, "Awwww," as his load explodes inside Pierce.
Pierce feels the warm ooze fill him up and moans again, stroking his still hard cock. Tanner fucks a few time and then slides his cum-covered cock out. He sits back on Pierce's lap and the two make-out.
"We better get cleaned up before the brothers start coming back," Pierce warns signaling the end to of their night together.
Tanner picks up his bedsheet and wraps it up into a toga again, "I guess I'll see you around?" Tanner says.
Pierce nods, "Anytime you'd like to 'Bond' with a big brother text me."
Tanner nods and smiles a fake smile, figuring it's a line Pierce always used on guys. Then Pierce stands up and kisses him. "I mean it, I don't want this to be our only time."
Tanner's smile become sincere, "Neither do I."  

If I were to choose between these two beefcakes, I'd go with Pierce.