Max Chevalier vs. Ethan Carter III

Chevalier is the French Canadian porn star made famous from topping guys in videos on Jimmy Z productions and Men of Montreal. Standing at 5'8", Chevalier comes in at a massive 185 lbs. Carter III, former Derrick Bateman from WWE, is now with TNA getting a much needed push. With the new organization Carter shaped up his 6'1" 225 lb body to perfection and hasn't looked better.

Carter bounces in one corner with his purple trunks, oiled skin glistening off the lights while Chevalier stands in the other, wearing short black shorts, flexing his muscles in preparation for the match. The two meet in the middle and get in a grapple, Carter knees Chevalier in the gut and hits him with a few blows, cornering him. Carter takes a few steps back and hits a leaping clothesline on Chevalier, causing him to fall forward on his knees. Carter picks him up and nails a flapjack. Chevalier lays dazed a moment before climbing to his feet. Carter smirks at his already beaten opponent and then goes in for another grapple. Carter tries for a suplex, but Chevalier blocks it and hits a neck breaker. Carter is stunned by the assault and gets up quickly trying for a clothesline. Chevalier ducks it and spins around, grabbing Carter. He lifts him up for an atomic drop. Carter lurches forward in pain. Chevalier wipes the sweat off his brow and grabs Carter, whipping him hard into the turnbuckle. Chevalier charges at him with a bodysplash, but Carter manages to catch the hunk. Carter laughs as he holds the big man, but Chevalier elbows him in the head a few times causing Carter to release him. Chevalier wraps his arms around Carter and gets him in a bearhug. Carter arches his back in pain, trying to squirm from the hold, but Chevalier's hold is tight. Carter punches Chevalier a few times, and finally Chevalier ends the hold with a belly to belly slam. Carter bounces across the ring and Chevalier goes for the cover. Carter throws the sweaty bodybuilder off of him and gets to his feet. The two lock up again, but Carter hits a frontface lock STO and goes for the surprise pin. Chevalier breaks it after a two-count. Both men get to their feet and square off again. In the midst of their grapple, Carter whips Chevalier into the ropes, Chevalier ducks under Carter's swing, bounces off the ropes but gets hit by a running forearm smash. Carter looks down at his fallen opponent, posing and showing off his impressive body. Chevalier rolls over and pulls himself up, but Carter is on him, pounding his back. He then grabs Chevalier and hits a northern lights suplex, bridging into a pin. Chevalier kicks out after two. Carter waits for Chevalier to get to his feet and goes for the one-percenter, but Chevalier dodges the move and hits Carter with a drop kick. Carter gets to his feet but is hit again by another dropkick. The third time, he raises his hands, blocking Chevalier's kick. Chevalier falls to the mat and Carter picks him up by his neck. He taunts the crowd and hits the one-percenter this time. He covers Chevalier and gets the three-count.

Carter walks into his bedroom and finds a man laying in his bed, a naked man. On closer inspection it's Chevalier, sound asleep. Naturally Carter slides into bed next to him, pulling his trunks off in the process. He stares at the sexy bodybuilder and then leans in for a kiss. A long kiss. Chevalier slowly opens his eyes and sees the hunk kissing him. He grabs Carter by the head and holds him for a make out session. Carter feels down below, grabbing Chevalier's hard cock. He breaks the kiss and dives down to suck Chevalier's cock. Chevalier pulls away, getting out of bed and standing up, luring Carter to follow. Carter crawls out of bed and moves in on his knees. Finally he grabs the dick and stuffs it in his mouth. Chevalier sighs as Carter bobs the dick in and out of his mouth, licking the shaft and the balls before sucking it back in. Chevalier pushes and pulls Carters head to and from his dick, his lips suctioning the tip of his head so that it never actually leaves his mouth. Chevalier could do this all night, but he wants a piece of Carter's ass before he cums. So, he slides his cock away from Carter's mouth and pushes him to the bed. Carter lays on his back as Chevalier crawls on top of him, reaching for his dick. The two men begin 69ing each other, Chevalier inhaling Carter's hard on like he hasn't had dick in years. Carter moans with Chevalier's dick in his mouth, the bodybuilder porn star knows how to give head as well as he can take it. Chevalier goes down with a deliberate pace, his head spinning as he goes down. Carter grips Chevaliers massive thighs as his tongue flicks at the cock dangling over him. He reaches up feeling Chevalier's massive ass, his finger exploring in between the cheeks. He slides his index finger in causing Chevalier to spit out his cock and sigh. Carter keeps sucking Chevalier's cock, which seems to be getting harder as his finger goes deeper. "You want that ass?" Chevalier asks. Carter tries answering with Chevalier's dick in his mouth, but can't be understood, so he spits it out and replies, "God yes." Chevalier sits up on his knees and bends his ass over Carter's face. Carter's eyes light up and he beginnings lick the ass being offered to him. His tongue rolls up Chevalier's ass to his hole, then traces the circumference of his hole. Chevalier sighs, leaning his hands on Carter's muscular legs for support. Carter flicks his tongue in and out of Chevalier's hole, which seems to be begging to get fucked. Carter gets his tongue in the hole, swirling around, pleasing Chevalier so much that he squirms. Finally he can't take it and gets off the wrestler and lays on his back. He holds his knees up, spread apart, inviting Carter to put his dick in. Carter spits on his dick, strokes the saliva in and then guides his cock into Chevalier's hole. Chevalier closes his eyes, sighing as he feels the warmth from Carter entering him. He holds his breath as Carter goes further in, exhaling as he pulls out. Carter starts fucking, his face hovering inches above Chevaliers, staring at Chevalier's eyelids, waiting for them to open. As Carter fucks at a steady pace Chevalier opens his eyes, smiling at the handsome face above him. Carter leans in for a kiss, but Chevalier hold him close. Carter pulls back and speeds up his thrusts. Chevalier's sighs become one long sigh as Carter flexes for him. Chevalier holds the base of his cock in one hand rubbing his pec with the other as Carter's fucks slow to hard thrusts. Each pounding comes with a little more force, but Chevalier can handle it. Carter wipes the sweat from his brow, and holds on to Chevalier's thighs as he goes in with another burst. Chevalier closes his eyes again, loving each time Carter hits his g spot. "Don't cum," he hears Carter say as he slows down. "Save some of that dick for me." Carter pulls his cock out of Chevalier and climbs on top of him. He sits his ass down on Chevalier's cock and bounces up and down on it. Chevalier feels up his rock solid abs to his chest, squeezing Carter's nipples as he controls the pace. "Yeah, that's it..." Carter says as he bobs his ass back down. He holds Chevalier's dick in him and swirls in his seat, letting Chevalier's cock spin in him. Chevalier grabs a hold of Carter's waist and starts pushing him up and down as his cock thrust up into him. Carter moans as Chevalier takes full control fucking his tight ass with all of his energy. The two men moan and sigh, each of them turning each other on more and more. Chevalier seems to get a second wind of energy and stands up, carrying Carter with him, dick still in ass. Carter hugs Chevalier as Chevalier pounds him some more. He sets Carter down on the dresser, half on, half dangling. Chevalier holds him by the waist and thrusts in with rapid fire. Carter moans, his eyes going wide, in disbelief of how much pleasure Chevalier can deliver. He feels up Chevalier's biceps, bulging as he holds Carter tight. Finally Chevalier stops, pulls out and cums all over Carter's stomach. He keeps stroking his cock long after all the juice has squirted out. Carter hops off the dresser and has Chevalier kneel before him. He rubs his dick and it explodes all over Chevalier's face. He then wipes his cock back and forth over Chevalier's lips, getting the sticky juice off. Chevalier stands up and gives Carter a long kiss, both men holding each other tight, their still hard dicks rubbing against each other.
If forced to choose between these two studs, I'd go with the serious Chevalier over the goofy Carter III.