Matthew Rush vs. Tank Toland

Rush is the "retired" porn legend with the beefy 6'0" 220 lb frame. Rush was is a versatile-top who has appeared in dozens of porn videos / scenes. While Toland is only 5'8" he comes packed with 225 lb of muscle. Toland is most famous for his brief stint as a member of the tag team The Dicks which had a sexy stripper gimmick, until a backstage altercation with his partner ousted them both.

Rush towers over Toland in the ring, yet Toland remains unphazed. The two men circle around the ring staring at each other, until they finally grapple with each other. Rush shoves Tank back into the turnbuckle and goes at him with a turnbuckle thrust to the gut. Rush follows up by giving Toland a bulldog. Rush gives a few elbow drops on the fallen Toland before picking him up and whipping him into the ropes. Rush connects with a back body drop, and Toland lands with a thud. Toland crawls around as Rush hammers his fists down on his back. Finally Toland gets to the ropes, and pulls himself up only for Rush to charge him with a clothesline, sending him out of the ring. Rush rolls out of the ring and picks Toland up to whip him into the barricade, but Toland reverses it and sends Rush hard into the metal wall. Both men are slow to recover but Rush charges at Toland with a clothesline. Toland ducks it and spins around and nails Rush with a dropkick. He then throws Rush back into the ring and follows him. Rush tries to regain control, kicking Toland as he comes into the ring. He then whips Toland into the ropes, Toland leapfrogs over him, bounces back and hits Rush with a crossbody block. They fall to the ring, Toland on top going for the pin but Rush kicks out after two. Toland and Rush get to their feet, Toland hits Rush with a few chops but Rush has no more of it and kicks Toland in the gut a few times. Rush then wraps his arms around Toland and gets him in a tight bearhug. He squeezes on Toland's muscles as his body presses up against his, but Toland squirms around and strikes Rush with some blows to the head. Finally Rush releases him, Toland bounces off the ropes and hits Rush with a spear. Rush falls hard and Toland continues sitting on top of him pounding away at him. Toland then picks Rush up and lifts the giant man up with a suspended suplex before sending him down to the mat. Toland gets on his feet waiting for the dazed Rush to turn to him and then nails a thrusting spinebuster. Rush is out of it and Toland hooks his leg for the three-count.

Rush walks into his bedroom and sees Toland already on the bed assuming the position. Hands and knees on his bed with his round butt facing out towards him, wagging as an invitation to be fucked. Rush wastes no time to strip down and stuff his lubed cock in. Toland grunts in pleasure as Rush works up some momentum with his fucks. The bubbly cheeks bounce off Rush's thick thighs as the dick gets pounded in harder with each progressive fuck. Rush grabs tightly onto Toland's shoulders as he fucks him and as Toland's ass grinds on the cock. As Rush takes a breather, Toland gets up and gives him a kiss. Rush picks up the beefy muscle men and holds him a hug as he slides his dick back up Toland's ass and fucks him as he carries him. Rush slowly makes his away across the room to a lounge chair where he rests. Toland rotates around the cock and fucks his ass down on Rush's thick wood, hitting his prostate. Just when he's about to cum he climbs off Rush's lap and picks up his legs. Toland aims his dick into Rush's hole and begins to fuck him. Rush moans in pleasure as Toland plows into him. Rush screams in joy as Toland hits him at the right angle, and tells him not to stop. Toland doesn't and with all of his strength goes faster until finally Rush cums all over himself. It doesn't take Toland too much longer to whip his cock out and squirt his load onto Rush. Even then he's not finished, and he sticks his sticky cock back in Rush and fucks him a few more times, making Rush squirm and sigh like a girl. He pulls out and rubs his wet dick on Rush's stomach, happy with his performance.
If I had to make a choice between these two beefcakes I'd choose the always in shape Toland and have him give me a strip show.