Tony Capucci vs. Robbie E

Capucci is a gay for pay performer who comes in at 5'11" and 180 lbs. Capucci made a splash when he debuted in 2007 and then after a couple of years, retired, only to make 2012 his comeback year, which resulted in just a few scenes before he disappeared again. E is the tan, cocky New Jersey stud who stands in at 5'11" (not including his frost tipped hair) and weighs 201 lbs.

If these two Italian-blooded studs faced off in a ring it would be a back and forth match for sure. While E has twenty pounds on Capucci, Capucci has the strength and agility to be able to stand his own. E would start the match showboating and dancing, prompting Capucci to take advantage of the opening and assault E with a fury of punches. Capucci would try to whip E to the corner turnbuckles, but E would reverse it sending Capucci hard to the corner and stumbling backwards out to the ring where he gets a dropkick to the face. After a few cheap kicks to the fallen Capucci, E would pick him up and throw him into the ropes and E would throw his body at Capucci to knock him down. Feeling confident, E would climb the turnbuckles and go for a high-risk attack, but Capucci would get up quick and knock E down on his crotch. The pain and shock of the attack would be a big opening for Capucci to give E a neckbreaker and a few legdrops of his own. E would probably fight back with some fists, but Capucci would lift E up and throw him out of the ring. By the time E crawled back into the ring, Capucci would grab him and stretch him out in a camel clutch, forcing him to submission.

Check out Tony Capucci at Cockyboys

If these two really got it on, it would ideally be a flip-fuck session because both of them have flawless asses that it would be a shame for either of them to go unpounded. E would probably want to take it slow at first and mount on Capucci's cock, slowly going up and down on it as his hole gets stretched. Once comfortable Capucci would probably take control and rabidly hump E, making him even fall off the bed as Capucci keeps thrusting. Once Capucci tires himself out, E would spread his legs and start pumping Capucci's tight ass until the two sweaty hunks came. 
Choosing between these two studs is tough, but ultimately I'm drawn to E. Even though he has the guido gimmick, his usually tan, oiled up body shines brighter.