Damien Holt vs. Titus O'Neil

Holt is 5'9' and 190 lbs. He appeared in a handful of scenes as a versatile performer and then unfortunately disappeared. Former footballer, O'Neil is 6'4 and 270 lb of jacked muscle and is known for his walrus like bark.

O'Neil taunts Holt with his signature bark. Holt smiles back, getting slightly harder as O'Neil circles the ring. The two grapple and O'Neil shoves Holt back into the ropes and chops him across the chest a few times. He then throws Holt into the ropes and hits him with a big boot when he bounces back. O'Neil lifts Holt up and hits  a backbreaker drop on his knee twice before lifting him up a third time and hitting a fallaway slam. Holt squirms in pain as Titus watches over him. O'Neil kicks Holt while he's down then goes for the pin but only gets a one count. Holt uses the ropes to climb to his feet, but O'Neil throws him in the turnbuckle and pounds at him. O'Neil takes a few steps back and hits a three-point stance splash. Damien slumps down to the ring while O'Neil celebrates. O'Neil lines up further for another three-point stance splash, but Holt rolls out of the way and he eats turnbuckle. Holt lifts himself to his feet using the ropes and then slingshots over landing on O'Neil. He hooks the leg but only gets a two count. Holt grabs O'Neil's head, O'Neil shoves Holt back and punches him a few times before clotheslining him. O'Neil picks Holt back up and wraps his arms around his waist, locking him in a bear hug. He lifts Holt up higher as he tightens the hold. Holt punches at O'Neil until he frees him, but he's weak and falls to the ground. O'Neil grabs Holt and whips him into the ropes. Holt ducks a clothesline and bounces back hitting O'Neil with a full body splash. He falls on top of O'Neil and goes for the pin, but gets a one count. Holt and O'Neil lock up, O'Neil tries for a suplex, but Holt blocks it and reverses it. Holt follows up with a few sledgehammers and then a leg drop. Holt quickly climbs to the top rope and waits for O'Neil to get up before leaping at him, hitting a full body splash. He rolls on top of O'Neil and manages to get the upset victory.

O'Neil walks in the lockerroom and sees Holt changing out of his football uniform. Holt glances back at O'Neil, watching him strip out piece by piece. O'Neil catches Holt and asks him what he's staring at. Holt doesn't say anything, but instead grabs O'Neil's crotch and rubs it through the spandex tights. O'Neil strips them down and guides Holt's head to his cock. Holt licks the tip and slowly down the shaft before inhaling it. O'Neil grinds as cock goes further down Holt's throat. Holt rotates his head, taking it in as his hands grab O'Neil's ass. His index finger sneaks into O'Neil's hole and tickles his inside. O'Neil pulls his dick out of Holt's mouth, "I'm not so sure about that..." Holt stands up and kisses O'Neil, "You telling me an ass like yours hasn't been fucked?" O'Neil shakes his head. Holt kisses him again, "I'll be gentle." He pushes O'Neil up against the lockers and guides his cock into the ass, slowly and not deep. O'Neil moans as if Holt had gone all the way in. Holt grinds slowly, easing O'Neil's tight hole. O'Neil sighs loudly, enjoying it. Holt thrusts his cock in deeper and then holds it. O'Neil moans, having never been touched this way. Holt pulls his dick out and fucks O'Neil again, going steady. O'Neil grips the top of the lockers as he asks for Holt to give it to him. Holt obliges and fucks harder, letting O'Neil's cheeks bounce off each other. O'Neil keeps screaming, enjoying it and working up a sweat. Finally O'Neil can't take the pounding any more and rests on a chair. Holt invites himself on to O'Neil's lap and squats down on his cock. O'Neil holds on to Holt's sides as he bounces up and down on the cock, letting it go all the way up his ass. O'Neil groans with pleasure as Holt continues to do all of the work. Holt leans forward still bopping on the dick. O'Neil grips the ass and start to get up, and now has a turn of directing the action. He fucks the bent over Holt hard, barking as his dick pounds the bubble ass. O'Neil keeps barking as he approaches climax and shoot his load all over Holt's back. Holt stands back up and turns around. O'Neil gets to his knees as Holt jerks his load out into his mouth. The two studs kiss passionately and head on to the showers.
If I were forced to choose between these two hunks of dark chocolate, I'd choose the versatile Holt.